How do taxes work for Canadian snowbirds in the U.S.?

How do taxes work for Canadian snowbirds in the U.S.?

At a glance:
  • The U.S. substantial presence test, which is used to determine your tax residency, looks at the weighted total of your days spent in the country over three calendar years.
  • Maintaining significant ties to Canada means you’re considered a Canadian resident for tax purposes and will report your worldwide income in Canada.
  • Even as a Canadian resident, you may still need to report U.S.-source income to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and may face state taxes.
  • Selling a U.S. property can create tax, filing and cash flow considerations in both countries.
  • Keeping track of your days in the U.S. and working with a financial advisor can help you prepare for tax season.

If you’re among the many Canadian retirees who spend part of the winter in the U.S., how long you stay can affect your residency status, tax-filing obligations and retirement-income planning. Understanding the tax and residency implications before you leave can help you keep better records and prepare for tax time.

Whether you’re a new snowbird or a veteran cross-border traveller, here’s what you need to know about your tax-filing requirements. 

In this article

Who qualifies as a snowbird?

The term “snowbird” is used to describe Canadians who spend their winters somewhere warmer, often in the U.S. From a tax perspective, however, your specific circumstances matter more than the label. Where you file, what you file and the tax you pay are based on your residency status and the amount of time you spend south of the border.

Where are you a tax resident?

If you spend part of the year in the U.S. but maintain significant residential ties to Canada, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) may consider you a resident of Canada for tax purposes (known as a factual resident). Significant residential ties can include:

  • a home owned or leased in Canada
  • a spouse or common-law partner who remains in Canada
  • dependants who remain in Canada

The CRA also considers secondary ties when determining your residency status, but these are looked at collectively rather than on their own. These might include:

  • economic ties, such as Canadian bank accounts and credit cards
  • personal property, such as vehicles and furniture
  • holding a Canadian passport, driver’s licence or health card
  • social connections, such as organization or association memberships

If you remain a factual resident, you’ll continue to report your worldwide income and file your taxes in the province or territory where your ties are strongest, usually the one you left before heading south.

However, if you’re considered a resident of both Canada and the U.S., treaty rules may be needed to determine your residence for tax purposes. This is a more complex situation that should be reviewed with a qualified tax professional.

Explore the Canadian income tax brackets and rates. 

Learn more

How long will you be in the U.S.?

The IRS uses the substantial presence test to decide whether you should be considered a resident alien, which is determined by the amount of time you spend across the border. U.S. residents must pay U.S. taxes on their worldwide income, while non-residents only need to pay U.S. taxes on income from U.S. sources.

The test uses a weighted calculation based on the number of days you spend in the U.S. across three years. You meet the substantial presence test if you’re physically present in the U.S. for

  • at least 31 days during the current year and
  • at least 183 weighted days over the three-year period.

To calculate your weighted total, add up

  • all your days in the U.S. during the current year,
  • one-third of your U.S. days during the prior year, and
  • one-sixth of your U.S. days during the year before that.

For example, suppose you spent 125 days in the U.S. in each of three consecutive calendar years. For the current year, your calculation would be:

  • 125 days from the current year
  • 42 days (125 ÷ 3) from the previous year
  • 21 days (125 ÷ 6) from two years earlier

Your weighted total would be 188 days, which means you would fail the IRS substantial presence test. However, meeting the test doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll be treated as a U.S. resident for tax purposes, as certain exceptions may apply.

If you’re travelling with someone else, you both need to count your own days individually. If you and your spouse arrive or leave on different dates, you should maintain a separate log. Any day you’re physically present in the U.S. for any part of the day typically counts as a day of presence, although certain exceptions apply.

Do you qualify for the closer connection exception?

Meeting the substantial presence test doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll be treated as a U.S. resident for tax purposes. The closer connection exception allows you to be treated as a non-resident for U.S. tax purposes if you

  • were present in the U.S. for fewer than 183 days during the current year,
  • maintained a tax home in another country throughout the year,
  • have a closer connection to that country than to the U.S., and
  • haven’t taken steps toward obtaining lawful permanent resident status in the U.S.

If your weighted day count is approaching or exceeds 183, it’s important to review your eligibility and filing requirements with a cross-border tax professional.

What tax forms do you need to file?

What you need to file depends on your circumstances. If you remain a Canadian factual resident, you may need to

On the U.S. side, you may have to complete the following forms:

  • Form 8840, Closer Connection Exception Statement for Aliens: If you’ve met the substantial presence test but want to claim the closer connection exception, you must file this form to claim the exception. The IRS specifically identifies Form 8840 as the form used to claim it.
  • Form 1040-NR, U.S. Non-Resident Alien Income Tax Return: Even if you’re not considered a U.S. resident, you may still have filing obligations on any income from U.S. sources. This can include rental income, gambling or lottery winnings and gains from selling a U.S. property.

Filing requirements also vary by state, and special rules may apply if you’re considered a resident of both Canada and the U.S. Consider consulting a cross-border tax professional to understand the requirements that apply to you.

Explore popular Canadian tax credits and deductions to help lower your tax bill.

Learn more

How does staying in the U.S. affect your retirement income?

Time away from Canada doesn’t change the structure of your retirement income on its own, but there may be tax considerations when you’re navigating two tax systems.

CPP/QPP, OAS and workplace pensions

If you remain a factual resident of Canada, you continue to report your taxable Canadian retirement income on your Canadian return. This may include Canada Pension Plan (CPP) or Quebec Pension Plan (QPP) benefits, Old Age Security (OAS) and workplace pension income.

The amount and timing of your income can affect

  • your marginal tax rate
  • whether tax instalments may be required
  • whether you’re subject to OAS recovery tax
  • the cash available for expenses in Canada and the U.S.

If your Canadian residency changes, the tax treatment of some retirement income may change as well. For example, Canadian withholding tax and Canada-U.S. tax treaty rules may apply differently.

A longer absence may also affect your provincial or territorial health coverage because each jurisdiction applies its own presence rules. It’s important to confirm the residency requirements for your province or territory before extending your trip.

RRSPs and RRIFs

As a Canadian resident, withdrawals from your Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) or Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) are reported as taxable income on your Canadian tax return. How much you withdraw, and when, can affect your taxable income. For RRIFs in particular, withdrawals above your required annual minimum are subject to withholding tax.

Before making a significant withdrawal, consider reviewing

  • your required RRIF minimum
  • your expected pension and OAS income
  • how much Canadian income you’ll need to cover U.S. expenses
  • the potential effect on income-tested benefits
  • whether your residency or U.S. tax status may change

If your residency changes, different withholding tax and treaty rules may apply to RRSP and RRIF withdrawals. Your financial advisor can help you coordinate your withdrawal and cash flow strategy with your broader retirement plan, while a tax professional can provide guidance on the Canadian and U.S. tax implications.

Explore RRIF withdrawal rules, withholding tax and how much you should receive.

Learn more

What if you decide to sell your U.S. property?

Selling a U.S. property can create filing and tax obligations in both countries.

Under the U.S. Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act (FIRPTA), the buyer may be required to withhold 15% of the sale price for the IRS. This can reduce the cash you receive at closing, even if your final U.S. tax liability is lower than the amount withheld.

You may need to file a U.S. return to report the sale, calculate the tax owing and potentially claim a refund of excess withholding. State-level tax may also apply.

If you remain a Canadian resident, you also need to report the sale and any resulting capital gain or loss on your Canadian return. You may be able to claim a Canadian federal foreign tax credit on the U.S. taxes you paid, which can help reduce double taxation of your income. Depending on your other U.S. holdings, foreign property reporting rules may also apply.

The bottom line

Spending winter in the U.S. doesn’t automatically make you a U.S. resident for tax purposes. However, repeated or longer stays can create additional filing obligations and affect how your income is reported.

By tracking your travel days, maintaining appropriate records and reviewing your retirement-income plans before you leave, you can be better prepared for tax season. A financial advisor can help coordinate the cash flow and investment planning elements of your retirement plan, while a qualified cross-border tax professional can help you understand which tax rules and filing obligations apply to you.

FAQs

How many days can you stay in the U.S. without paying U.S. tax?

There’s no universal number that determines whether you’ll owe U.S. tax. The substantial presence test considers a weighted three-year day count, so staying fewer than 183 days in the current calendar year doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll avoid U.S. tax residency. Certain exceptions may also apply. The IRS test requires at least 31 days in the current year and 183 weighted days over the applicable three-year period.

Will spending winter in the U.S. affect your CPP, OAS or pension?

If you remain a Canadian factual resident, CPP/QPP, OAS and workplace pension income may continue to be reported on your Canadian return. Their combined amount may affect your overall tax bill and income-tested benefits, and a change in residency could result in different withholding tax or treaty treatment.

How are RRIF withdrawals taxed while in the U.S.?

If you remain a Canadian resident, RRIF withdrawals continue to be included in your taxable income in Canada. If your residency or U.S. tax status changes, additional withholding and treaty rules may apply.

Can you claim a foreign tax credit for U.S. tax paid?

You may be able to claim a Canadian foreign tax credit for qualifying U.S. tax paid, subject to applicable Canadian limits and treaty rules. Keep supporting documents related to your U.S. income and taxes paid in case the CRA asks to see them. The CRA specifically requires supporting documentation for foreign tax credit claims.