Why sustainable investing does not mean lower returns

One of the enduring myths about sustainable investing is that doing good comes at a price. You can have a clean conscience or investment gains, but not both at the same time. At Fidelity, we believe this is simply not the case.

Is sustainable investing profitable?

To test this hypothesis, Fidelity International performed a comparison across all 2,659 companies covered by Fidelity’s equity analysts and 1,450 in our fixed income universe.

It was a simple test. We ranked the companies we follow on the basis of their ESG merits, so it was an easy enough job to see whether stock market performance was correlated to our A-E rating system.

We conducted our analysis in October 2020 using data for the first nine months of the year and we were delighted, although not altogether surprised, to see that the most highly-rated companies performed best, followed by the second most highly-rated group and so on, all the way down to the worst-rated and worst-performing category.

The correlation was linear. Each group beat the one below it, from A down to E.

 

Does sustainable investing lead to lower returns?

No. The top-rated A and B groups actually beat the lowest rated D and E categories in each of the nine months except one, and even that exception proved rather than undermined our central claim.

That’s because the outlier was April, the month in which markets bounced back most strongly from the heavy falls experienced in February and March. Very often, when a market recovers from a big sell-off, it is the lowest-quality shares which bounce fastest because they have been hardest hit in the downturn.

So, all nine months in the study confirmed the apparent link between strong environmental, social and governance scores and good management. Sustainability does seem to be a kind of proxy for quality.

This correlation actually poses a tricky question. It suggests that maybe the real reason for the outperformance is not a company’s ESG credentials but simply its quality. If that is the case, then we might simply be confusing correlation with causation.

 

Do ESG investments outperform?

To settle that question, we sliced and diced our universe of companies another way. This time we collected the companies in five buckets on the basis of their return on equity (a shorthand for quality). Then, within each of these groups, we did the same ESG ranking. We found, to our relief, that whichever quality bucket you chose, the link between ESG rating and stock market performance held true.

One other thing Fidelity analysts do when looking at companies is to decide whether their ESG qualities are improving, staying the same or deteriorating. We wondered whether this might be a predictor of performance too. And, sure enough, we found that companies with an improving ESG profile outperformed stable ones which in turn outperformed those where attention to environmental, social and governance factors is getting worse.

By the way, we found a similar effect when we looked at bond performance and ESG ratings. The correlation was not quite as strong as it is with stocks, but the evidence is still compelling.

 

Bottom line

This analysis is powerful because it appears to have worked in both down and up markets in 2020. Regardless of whether investors find themselves in a bull or a bear market, focusing on companies that take sustainability seriously can be rewarding. The market seems to discriminate between companies based on their approach to ESG.

This is not just an argument for investing in funds with an explicit sustainability focus. It is also an argument for backing investment firms with a track record of integrating ESG factors into their analytical approach.

In the extraordinary market conditions of 2020, you might have thought that sustainability was a luxury you could do without, putting environmental concerns, stakeholder welfare and corporate governance on the back burner to focus instead on maximizing profits, whatever the cost. In fact, the reverse is the case. Doing the right thing makes good investment sense too.

What to learn more about sustainable funds? Check out the following funds from Fidelity:





Fidelity Sustainable World ETF

ESG Strategy: Best-in-class and exclusionary screening

Fidelity Sustainable World ETF and Mutual Fund is a global multi-factor equity strategy designed to provide strong risk-adjusted returns by investing in companies with favourable environmental, social and governance characteristics.






Fidelity Women’s Leadership Fund

ESG Strategy: ESG Integration and thematic

Fidelity Women’s Leadership Fund is a core U.S. equity strategy that aims to deliver strong risk-adjusted returns by investing primarily in companies that prioritize and advance women’s leadership and development across their organization.







The practices described in this article reflect the investment practices of Fidelity Investments Canada ULC (“FIC”) and Fidelity International Limited. These practices may not be representative of the investment practices of FIC’s other subadvisors, including Fidelity Management and Research Co. and Geode Capital Management.

Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees, brokerage fees and expenses may be associated with investments in mutual funds and ETFs. Please read the mutual fund’s or ETF’s prospectus, which contains detailed investment information, before investing. Mutual funds and ETFs are not guaranteed. Their values change frequently, and investors may experience a gain or a loss. Past performance may not be repeated.

The statements contained herein are based on information believed to be reliable and are provided for information purposes only. Where such information is based in whole or in part on information provided by third parties, we cannot guarantee that it is accurate, complete or current at all times. It does not provide investment, tax or legal advice, and is not an offer or solicitation to buy. Graphs and charts are used for illustrative purposes only and do not reflect future values or returns on investment of any fund or portfolio. Particular investment strategies should be evaluated according to an investor’s investment objectives and tolerance for risk. Fidelity Investments Canada ULC and its affiliates and related entities are not liable for any errors or omissions in the information or for any loss or damage suffered.

© 2021 Fidelity Investments Canada ULC. All rights reserved.

Commissions, fees and expenses may be associated with investment funds. Read a fund’s prospectus or offering memorandum and speak to an advisor before investing.  Funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and investors may experience a gain or loss.  Past performance may not be repeated.

Read our privacy policy.  By using or logging in to this website, you consent to the use of cookies as described in our privacy policy.

This site is for persons in Canada only.  Mutual funds and ETFs sponsored by Fidelity Investments Canada ULC are only qualified for sale in the provinces and territories of Canada.

511786-v2021316

Close Search